Rent-to-Own vs Buying a Used Car: Which Costs Le...

Rent-to-own vs buying a used car in South Africa — which costs less? A detailed cost comparison covering insurance, maintenance, and total ownership costs.

The Real Cost Question

When South Africans need a car, the instinct is often to buy a used one. It seems cheaper upfront. But when you add up insurance, repairs, tracking, and the risk of buying a problem vehicle --- the picture changes.

The Upfront Cost Difference

Buying a Used Car:

----------------------------------- ----------------------------------- Cost Amount

Purchase price R80,000 -- R180,000

Transfer fees R500 -- R1,000

Licensing R500 -- R800

Insurance (first month) R800 -- R2,500

Tracking installation R1,500 -- R3,000

Total upfront R83,300 -- R187,300 ----------------------------------- -----------------------------------

Rent-to-Own (EzAuto):

----------------------------------- ----------------------------------- Cost Amount

Deposit R7,000 -- R30,000 (security, not a purchase payment)

First monthly rental From R5,500

Total upfront From R12,500 ----------------------------------- -----------------------------------

Monthly Running Costs: Side-by-Side

----------------------- ----------------------- ----------------------- Cost Buying Used Rent-to-Own (EzAuto)

Insurance R1,200/month ✅ Included

Tracking R250/month ✅ Included

Roadside assist R200/month ✅ Included

Maintenance R500/month R500/month (your responsibility)

Unexpected repairs R400/month average Supported by ELVR\\* ----------------------- ----------------------- -----------------------

*\\*EzAuto's Limited Vehicle Responsibility (ELVR) is EzAuto's commitment to ensuring every vehicle in its fleet is roadworthy and well-maintained. It is not a warranty and not insurance --- it is EzAuto's own quality assurance standard applied to every vehicle rented.*

Hidden Risks of Buying Used

Risk 1: Buying a Problem Car

A single engine or gearbox failure can cost R15,000--R40,000. EzAuto vehicles are independently inspected before handover.

Risk 2: No Insurance Protection

Many used car buyers skip comprehensive insurance to save money. One accident or theft and you've lost everything.

Risk 3: Administrative Burden

Insurance shopping, tracker subscriptions --- you manage everything yourself. With rent-to-own, it's all handled.

When Buying Used Makes Sense

  • You have R100,000+ in savings you can afford to spend
  • You are mechanically savvy or have a trusted mechanic
  • You can budget separately for insurance, tracking, and maintenance
  • You want the lowest possible long-term cost and accept the risks

When Rent-to-Own Makes Sense

  • You don't have large savings for a cash purchase
  • You want everything covered in one monthly payment
  • You value the security of a quality, inspected vehicle
  • You've been declined through traditional channels
  • You want predictable costs with no surprises

If You Exit Early

If the agreement ends before the end of the rental period for any reason attributable to you, EzAuto is entitled to retain some or all of your deposit as a reasonable cancellation charge. Additional charges may also apply. There is a minimum commitment period of 6 months.

The Bottom Line

Buying a used car is cheaper in total if you have the cash and accept the risks. Rent-to-own costs more in total but offers lower barriers to entry, all-inclusive coverage, and a quality inspected vehicle. Choose based on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and priorities.

Ready to Compare?

Apply online in under 5 minutes --- pre-approval within 60 seconds.